The recent high profile signing of the National Health Insurance Act set me thinking about the public perceptions of healthcare in South Africa. In a South African context one hears much about problems experienced in the public health sector but less about those in the private health sector. In the public health sector issues relate to the poor quality of healthcare while in the private sector the issue most frequently is the high cost of services. I have had the advantage of having worked for forty years in the South African public health sector and subsequent to my retirement being part of, or having undertaken, various investigations into public health…
-
-
2023 … some reflections on the year that was!
At this time last year I published a similar post reflecting on the happenings of 2022. It is interesting to reflect on what I said then in the light of what has transpired in 2023. In December of 2022, the echoes of COVID-19 still remained, something that has now almost vanished from the public consciousness despite reports of new variants, similar to the amnesia that may follow a very traumatic event. In Britain, however, the country continues to anguish over the consequences of what was and what was not done during the pandemic in the public hearings of a commission of inquiry into the actions of those in positions of…
-
Cystic fibrosis … the conundrum of scientific progress
I recently read a review article on cystic fibrosis which highlighted for me the tremendous advances in the field of medicine since I left active clinical practice as a paediatrician in 1995. During my training as a paediatrician and subsequently as a senior research fellow I worked for various periods in a clinic at the Red Cross Children’s Hospital that managed children with cystic fibrosis. As a result of this experience when in 1983 I moved to Bloemfontein, I started a similar clinic to manage children with the condition in the Free State province. Over the 12 years that I spent in the Department of Paediatrics and Child Health at…
-
Nutrition … a marker of poverty or privilege
A recent headline in the Daily Maverick read as follows, “Child malnutrition in the Eastern Cape qualifies as a disaster” quoting from a South African Human Rights Commission report on child malnutrition in the Eastern Cape province. The article cited the fact that 25% of the provinces’s children have stunted growth and over the period of one year over 1000 children were diagnosed with severe malnutrition of whom 120 died. Juxtapose this with a more recent media headline in a Afrikaans National Sunday Newspaper which reads translated from the Afrikaans, “You cough up R24 000 per head so that Cyril’s (the State President) guests can feast while they fly”. The…
-
South Africa … how long are the shadows of apartheid?
In recent days both President Ramaphosa and a cabinet minister have attributed current issues in South Africa to the legacy of apartheid. Without doubt legacies of apartheid remain in this country almost thirty years after the birth of a democratic and non-racial South Africa. Glaring examples of this are the spatial distribution of South Africans and the significant differential of income and employment amongst South Africans which in large measure remains defined by race. However, can the tragic events of a fire in a “hijacked” Johannesburg building be attributed to apartheid as was done by a cabinet minister? Is the poor state of many municipalities across the country due to the…
-
National Health Insurance … potential for system failure?
I recently read about the two disasters affecting the American Space Shuttles. The Challenger exploded shortly after launch in 1985 while the Columbia was destroyed 20 years ago over Texas on its 2003 return to earth after a 16-day mission. In both cases an accident investigation board (AIB) was established to investigate the causes of the disasters and make recommendations to address what had occurred. In the case of Challenger, a faulty o-ring on one of the solid rocket booster rockets, due to the abnormally cold weather during the launch, lead to flames leaking from the rocket igniting a catastrophic explosion in the shuttle’s external fuel tank destroying of the space…
-
Hospitals are key to an effective health service
Having recently been a patient requiring major surgery in a hospital, I have reflected on the vital nature of a fully functional hospital to the integrity of a health service. Despite spending half my professional life as a clinician working in a hospital, being a patient requiring complex care without which I may not have been here today to write this, provided me with another perspective. Hospitals, be they in the public or private health sector, are complex organisations focused on, and vital to the well being of the patients admitted to their wards. Hospitals are essential to provide a range of services that cannot be provided elsewhere which is…
-
Livingstone Hospital … a case study worth analysing
A recent media report revealed that some patients admitted to Livingstone Hospital a large provincial hospital located in Gqeberha, Eastern Cape are apparently given a letter which reads as follows: You have been admitted to Livingstone Hospital because you require emergency/urgent treatment for an orthopaedic condition. Unfortunately, the implants (metal devices used to fix broken/deformed bones) needed to best treat you are not currently available in the hospital. Depending on your injury and the delay the implant unavailability causes, you might not be able to be treated surgically and have a poor result/outcome. Your doctors have not been informed when implants will again be available nor given any alternative hospitals…
-
Gauteng Health Department woes are not new
In February 2017 after the release of the damning report by the Health Ombud Professor Makgoba on what happened subsequent to the disastrous transfer of mental health patients from Life Esidemeni to ill-prepared NPO’s, the then Minister of Health Dr. Aaron Motsoaledi and the then Premier of Gauteng David Makhura announced the appointment of a high-level task team to address what were termed “critical inadequacies in the capacities and capabilities and competencies to run the system and the management and incapacities exposed by the Life Esidimeni tragedy.” I was a member of that five-person task team for four months working in Gauteng. Ultimately I resigned in frustration as the team’s work…
-
Being a patient provides another perspective!
For most of February 2023 I was a patient in hospital requiring two laparotomies, a spell on a ventilator, two weeks in intensive care discharged home after just over three weeks. Somewhat chastened by the experience I am now 10kg lighter than when admitted and recuperating at home. Certainly an experience of this nature brought me face to face with my own mortality but also emphasised the impact that sudden severe illness has on those close and dear to one. I am grateful that the pathology that required surgery was not malignancy and could be rectified by the surgical interventions. However, the experience brought home to me the crucial importance…