• Health commentary,  Health Commentary,  Political commentary

    Cholera in South Africa … is it a marker of government failure?

    As a paediatrician I specialised in childhood diseases of the gastrointestinal tract. I obtained a doctorate for a study of infants presenting to the Red Cross Children’s Hospital in Cape Town with acute diarrhoea. In the introductory chapter of my thesis, I quoted the researchers Rohde and Northrup (1975) who stated that, “the incidence of diarrhoea is more closely related to socioeconomic conditions than to climate, to poverty rather than place.” At that time (1981-1982) diarrhoea in infants was an annual summer epidemic in Cape Town located largely amongst the black and coloured communities of the Cape Flats. In recent times the frequency of the disease amongst children from these…

  • Health commentary,  Political commentary

    André de Ruyter … Truth to Power … a must read!

    I have just finished reading André de Ruyter’s book Truth to Power My Three Years Inside Eskom, which I believe should be read by South Africans interested in why the country is the way it is today. Unlike de Ruyter, I spent my whole professional life in the public sector, while he entered Eskom as the CEO having only worked in the private sector. He acknowledges that he completely underestimated the constraints imposed on him as the Eskom CEO by the public service regulations and processes as well as political oversight. As with de Ruyter when I moved from a clinical role in health services into management in 1994, I experienced…

  • Political commentary

    Leadership … it’s what South Africa urgently needs!

    Leading a country, a business and even a sports team is not an easy task. In the “olden days”, the king or emperor would lead his soldiers into battle risking his life at the forefront of the fighting. Those who would be king could not be weak or indecisive as the consequences were dire. Similarly, the CEO of a successful company or the captain of a winning sports team must lead from the front and be able to decide to change strategy when an initial strategy is failing. Decisive leadership not necessarily group consensus is a mark of success. Recent reports reflect the frustration of business leaders with the indecisiveness…

  • Health commentary,  Political commentary

    National Health Insurance in South Africa … will logic prevail?

    Following my last post describing an analogy between the space shuttle disasters and the possibility of a system failure following the envisaged implementation of National Health Insurance (NHI) in South Africa my thoughts have returned to what I wrote in March 2022. This post reflected on the alternatives to what is proposed in the South African model of NHI. As I wrote then since 1994 the divide between those who have the ability to afford what in South Africa is termed private healthcare and those dependent on the State operated Public Health Service for the provision of healthcare has regrettably grown. The widening gap cannot be laid at the door…

  • Political commentary

    Elected politicians and appointed public servants … at times a fraught relationship!

    Mr Dominic Raab, the United Kingdom Deputy Prime Minister and Secretary of State for Justice resigned recently.  The reasons for his resignation highlight the at times fraught relationship between an elected politician and appointed public (civil) servants. Mr Raab was alleged to have bullied and humiliated officials in various ministries. Bullying was defined for the purpose of this inquiry as follows: (1) Offensive, intimidating, malicious or insulting behaviour; or (2) Abuse or misuse of power in ways that undermine, humiliate, denigrate or injure the recipient . The inquiry, conducted by a senior British advocate, Adam Tolley KC, tested the allegations against the 2019 version of what in the United Kingdom…

  • Health commentary,  Political commentary

    Politics, policy and implementation … there is a vast difference!

    President Ramaphosa speaking at the 5th South African Investment Conference on 13th April 2023 made the following statements; “We are now confronted with the consequences of years of under-investment, mismanagement and corruption in our electricity, rail and logistics sector.” and that, “We are on a long journey to rebuild our country and recover ground we have lost. Our recovery is a mission and will take time to accomplish”. He continued that, “The lack of reliability in electricity supply weakens business and consumer confidence, taints international perceptions about our country and affects investment sentiment and decisions” concluding that, “If the focus of our struggle for liberation to end apartheid and achieve political freedom, the focus of our efforts must be to address inequality…

  • Health commentary,  Political commentary

    2022 …the year that was!

    As we enter the last days of 2022, it is worthwhile to reflect on some of the events impacting on the health sector in the year that was. It was an eventful year with both the good and bad. Those who have read my posts during 2022 may feel that I concentrate too frequently on the negative and rarely focus on the positive. That may be true but I only reflect the world around me as I see it. I accept that there are amongst us many good people doing great things who are rarely acknowledged and I also accept that maybe I have failed to focus enough on them.…

  • Health commentary,  Political commentary

    National Health Insurance … noble in intent but is it a bridge too far?

    In the summer of 1944 during the Second World War the Allies launched an airborne operation, named Market Garden, aimed at securing a crossing over the Rhine River and thus an advance into the heart of Northern Germany. The aim of the operation was to seize key bridges with airborne troops allowing ground troops to advance over 100 kilometres to the Dutch town of Arnhem and by so doing outflank the German frontier defences. The plan which was backed by the British General Montgomery and Prime Minister Churchill despite concerns expressed by others in the Allied High Command lead by General Eisenhower. The operation despite the heroic efforts of allied…

  • ESCOM,  Health commentary,  Political commentary

    Management decisions right or wrong must have consequences.

    Recent experience with almost month-long power cuts in South Africa due to inadequate generation capacity have highlighted a State-owned entity has been unable to ensure a reliable source of electricity to the country for over a decade. When this first occurred in 2008, I was heading the Western Cape Department of Health and as management we had urgent meetings with officials from the power utility to decide how to manage what was envisaged then to be a short-term problem. At that time many health facilities had inadequate or no back-up generators and a decision was taken and actioned urgently to acquire and install generators at as many facilities as fast…

  • Health commentary,  Political commentary

    Gift of the Givers and a Vaccine Task Force … lessons to be learnt … revisited.

    It is worth reading my post of December 2021 again and then watching the link below to a recent Twitter post featuring a short input from Dr Imitiaz Sooliman. Well said Dr Sooliman! What we need is action and deeds by capable people as the answer to the challenges faced in South Africa today! https://twitter.com/nosh15/status/1550421503489019906?s=20&t=9PBoHEZ7i_MO8KdrdlWVJw